Wednesday, July 10, 2019

Book Review: Karl Marx by David McLellan


I am writing this review after almost six years. I read this book back in summer 2013. Karl Marx was born in Trier in 1818 and he died in 1893.

Marx spent a lot of his time with Young Hegelian intellectuals. He tried his career in journalism. Marx was expelled from Paris for subversive journalism. He met Engels who was the son of a Rhenish cotton spinner. Engels brought Marx a practical acquaintance with the workings of capitalism, provided source of financial assistance and one firm friendship that Marx enjoyed throughout his life. Marx could not complete his work on political economy due to his involvement in the International Workingmen’s Association, commonly known as the first International.

For Marx the proletariat was destined to assume the universal role that Hegel had misleadingly assigned to the bureaucracy. Marx wrote about alienated labor. This labor had four aspects to it. First, the worker was related to his labor as to an alien objet. Second, the worker did not view his work as part of his real life. Third, man’s social essence was taken away from him in his work which did not represent the harmonious efforts of man as a “species being”. Fourth, man found himself alienated from other men.

Marx considers “communism as the positive abolition of private property and thus of human self-alienation and therefore the real re-appropriation of the human essence by and for man. This is communism as the complete and conscious return of man himself as a social, i.e., human being.”

Discussing history, the author quotes from the Communist Manifesto: “The history of all hitherto existing societies is the history of a class struggles.” Marx wrote that “society as a whole is more and more splitting up into two great classes directly facing each other: bourgeoisie and proletariat”: and the same view reappears in capital. Marx espouses a materialist conception of history.

Explaining economics, the author states that Marx gave the labor theory of value, according to which the value of objects was measured by the amount of Labor embodied in them. Marx paints a grim picture of the fate of the working class. He says that “within the capitalist system all methods for raising the social productiveness of labor are brought about at the cost of the individual laborer”. It was Engels, in 1844 who guided Marx’s interest to economics and introduced him at first hand to British Capitalism. Engels survived Marx by thirteen years. He was the keeper of Marx’s archives and began editing his manuscripts of the remaining volumes of Capital.

Under the theme of politics Marx main target was the state. He considered state as the central institution of capitalist society. Marx viewed state as an instrument of class domination. The large-scale industry and universal competition of modern capitalism had created their own political organization- the modern liberal democratic state under which the bourgeoisie could best develop its class potential. Moreover, he believes that after a successful proletarian revolution there would be a period of transition which he occasionally referred to as “the dictatorship of the proletariat”. He associated the word dictatorship with the Roman office of dictatura, where all power was legally concentrated in the hands of a single man during a limited period in a time of crisis.

Marx appeared to be a philosopher, a humanist with not only a devastating account of the alienation of man in capitalist society but also in rich and varied account of the potential latent in every individual waiting to be realized under communism. Later in many developing nations Marxism combined with nationalism functions as an ideology for mass participation in the modernization process. The author substitutes the people of Asia, Africa, and Latin America as “external proletariat” in the place of the industrial working class in which Marx placed such hope.

The ideas of Marx have been an inspiration and has had a significant impact on a large section of humanity over the last century.

0 comments:

Post a Comment