Sunday, June 16, 2019

Book Review: The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State by Frederick Engels


Frederick Engels wrote this book between March and May 1884. Originally written in German, appearing in book form first in 1884, the English translation of this got published in 1891. Based on nine interesting chapters, the author has starts from ancient stages of prehistoric culture and ends with the critique of civilization.

Engels believes Morgan was the first person who attempted to introduce a definite order into the prehistory of human kind. This order includes savagery, barbarism and civilization. Engels mentions Morgan dividing savagery and barbarism into lower, middle and upper stages according to the progress made in food production.  During the lower stages of savagery human race depended on fruits, nuts and roots. Crabs, mussels and aquatic animals came in the next stage.  This became possible with the use of fire. The upper stage of savagery began with the invention of bow and arrow. In this stage game became a regular source of food. Bow and arrow was for savagery what the iron sword was for barbarism and fire-arms for civilization- the decisive weapon.

Moreover in chapter two Engels again refers to Morgan. He explains Morgan reference to unrestricted sexual relations. This unrestricted sexual relation prevailed within every tribe, every woman belonging equally to every man and very man to very woman. According to Morgan the primitive state of unregulated sexual intercourse developed very early. Engels discusses consanguine family, Punaluan family and the pairing family. The increase in prohibitions made group marriages more and more impossible and they were displaced by the pairing family. The author writes about the overthrow of mother right with the decision that in the future offspring of male members should remain within that genes.

In addition to that Engels believes: “Modern individual family is founded on the open or concealed domestic slavery of women, and modern society is a mass composed of these individual families as its molecules.” During the three principal stages of human development the forms of marriages developed. In the first stage of savagery group marriage developed. In the second stage of Barbarism pairing marriage came into place. In the last stage of civilization monogamy supplemented by adultery and prostitution developed. The writer views monogamy to have arisen from the concentration of large wealth in the hands of single individual-man.

With private property gaining ascendency over communal property and with the father right getting more prominent the dependency of marriages on economic considerations became even greater. Furthermore Engels suggests that supremacy of man in marriage is only due to his economic supremacy. The abolition would disappear once the economic supremacy ends.

In chapter three Engels addresses the Iroquois Gens of Americas. He writes about their prevalent hierarchy. Each tribe has a particular dialect, tribal council for common affair is present and war chiefs are elected. The Iroquois Confederacy had no powerful head and no chief with executive power. Outside the tribe was considered outside the law.

Chapter number four focuses on the Greek Gens. Engels quotes Grote’s A History of Greece. The Greeks had a common burial place. Right of adoption into the gens, right to elect chiefs and to depose them were present. The fifth chapter is about the rise of the Athenian state. The Athenian people fused into a single people. A common Athenian Civil law arose above the legal customs of tribes and gentes. The entire people were divided into three classes. This included tillers of land, artisans and nobility. Nobility only had the right hold office. In Athens there was no supreme official with executive power.

The author covers The Gens and the State in Rome in chapter six. The first constitution of the Roman people mentioned that public affairs were managed by the Senate. The Senate composed of the Chiefs of the 300 gentes. The Romans in the age of the so-called kings lived in a military democracy founded on gentes, phratries and tribes and developed out of them.

Chapter seven focuses on The Gens among the Celts and Germans. Among the Germans respect for female sex was very firmly in place. The thought of the wives and daughters taken captive or into slavery was terrible to them. Chastity for girls was maintained unlike the Celts. Among the Germans private associates had already become permanent. A military leader who had made himself a name gathered around him a band of young men eager for booty who he pledged to personal loyalty, giving the same pledge to them. Under the chapter formation of the state among the Germans the author emphasizes that “all that was vigorous and life-giving which the Germans infused into the Roman world was barbarian.”

In the last chapter Engels considers separation of pastoral tribes from the mass of the rest of barbarians as the first great social division of labor. Cattle-the chief article acquired a money function and already at this stage did the work of money. For the first great social division of labor arose the first great cleavage of society into two classes: masters and slaves, exploiters and exploited.

Engels believes that emancipation of woman becomes possible only when woman take part in production on a larger scale. Engels considers merchants as the class which without any participation in production subjugates the producers. This is a class of middleman which exploits any two producers.

Engels writes about how private land property, money, trade expansion and usury played a role in economies. Furthermore the arising of the state is described. Athens is considered as the purist example. Here the state sprang directly and mainly out of the class antagonisms which develop within gentile society itself. Hegel’s definition of state is also provided. Hegel believed that state would moderate conflict between classes with conflicting economic interests. State distinguishes itself from the old gentile organization on territorial basis, public power, taxes, and national debts.

Furthermore civilization is elaborated by Engels. “It is the stage of development in society at which the division of labor, the resulting exchange between individuals, and commodity production which combines them both, come to their full growth and revolutionizes the whole of previous society. Slavery is the first form of exploitation, the form peculiar to the ancient world, it is succeeded by serfdom in the Middle Ages, and wage labor in modern times.

Engels criticizes civilization: “From the first day to this, sheer greed has been the driving spirit of civilization; wealth and gain wealth and once more wealth, wealth, not of society but of this single-party individual- here was its one and final aim.” The more civilization advances it would introduce a conventional hypocrisy unknown to earlier forms of society.


0 comments:

Post a Comment